Leave a comment

Comments 5

batgurl10 July 4 2011, 17:58:18 UTC
this is one of my MOST favorite sherlock/john stories. Seriously, I could swim in this verse and never come up for air its that good. I do hope author is willing to revisit this verse and give us MOAR!

a MUST read for sure!

Reply

circejd July 4 2011, 18:41:12 UTC
Yep, nice to see a fic which maintains quality with the quantity:0)

Reply


mustbehavingfun July 4 2011, 18:28:39 UTC
Can't believe this didn't get 5 slashes - definitely my favourite thing in the fandom.

Reply

circejd July 4 2011, 18:47:05 UTC
A couple of reasons for this:

Firstly, I found some of the dialogue just didn't "sound" right and secondly a Britpicker would have helped with that and a few of the other language/culture issues. The 4 slashes certainly isn't a comment on the quality of this verse. Limitations of our "ratings system" I'm afraid.

It's definitely up there in my faves list though.

Reply

mustbehavingfun July 4 2011, 19:02:49 UTC
Ah, that's fair. It's weird, the lack of britpicking hadn't bothered me, really (I normally stop reading the minute I notice inaccuracies), but flicking through now I can see a few things that might be distracting.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up