Leave a comment

Comments 9

nvr2blonde August 15 2004, 19:26:22 UTC
I get annoyed too. That she's created such incredible characters and then just seems to leave them in the dust.

Draco and Snape could be *so* developed. I get very frustrated. It's very much a love/hate relationship between me and JKR. Seriously.

But yes, read the books. They are good, for what they are. I will forever mourn what they *could* have been, however.

Reply

frau_r August 15 2004, 20:00:36 UTC
Hmmm. They are not bad, that's for sure, but compared to some actually great literature they seem pretty overappreciated at the moment. I share your mourning: the fantasy world and its characters had a chance to become unforgettable literature, but forcing it into a simplisistic good/evil mold will make short work of that.

Reply


milasmith August 15 2004, 19:49:39 UTC
Perhaps.

But 'it ain't over till it's over'. I keep reminding myself that its supposed to be a children's book. I think it got re-categorized after Cedric died.

Reply

frau_r August 15 2004, 20:02:26 UTC
However, that's really not an excuse in my opinion. Children need more books with complex moral issues and multi-faceted characters - adults underestimate their ability to deal with such things (that's my opinion, anyway). Of course, I read adults' books even before I went to school so perhaps I am a bit different from a typical kid...

Reply


I love Ron Weasley! jariket August 17 2004, 00:28:31 UTC
Maybe I lucked out. I worked in a book store during the height of the Harry Potter craze. I loathed Harry Potter for years! All those little bastards pestering me every time we sold out.

My boyfriend persuaded me to go see the first film. I stopped hating Harry Potter but still had no real inclination to read the books. After over a year of pestering Aaron (the boyfriend) persuaded me to read them. I loved them. Ron Weasley is my new favorite thing.

My point is I had zero expectations for the books. I believe that is why I loved them. The plot was simple at points but I never stopped enjoying myself.

I have never read any Harry Potter slash so I can't compare the two.

Reply

Re: I love Ron Weasley! frau_r August 20 2004, 20:12:51 UTC
It's nice if you like it. It is by no means *bad*! Ron is really not my thing... I mean, he can be funny and all, but doesn't really touch me the way Draco and Snape do.

Reply

Re: I love Ron Weasley! jariket August 21 2004, 11:20:45 UTC
I don't really care for Draco. I love Snape though I think that started because he was played by Alan Rickman.

Reply


(The comment has been removed)

frau_r August 20 2004, 20:14:30 UTC
Thanks! :)

And yes, I hope she'd just keep writing and stop moralizing and belittling her fans. (If I can even be called that any more).

I tell you what, I'll wait until my friends have read the next book and ask if a rabid Draco fan can handle what ever happens in it...

Reply


lady_arrogance October 12 2004, 17:32:11 UTC
I know this feeling... I really prefer the ffs and especially most of the fandon Dracos. In the book, he has absolutely no personality and is just a... in german it's called a softegg ;)
But I think I will read the next books anyway, because I hate not to finish something I started...

Reply


Leave a comment

Up