Round 3 // Challenge 8 Results

Mar 26, 2011 18:38

No Mod's Choice this week given we had a tie for Members' Choice.

Challenge 8 Results )

round 3, results, challenge 8

Leave a comment

Comments 11

(The comment has been removed)

shadowserenity March 27 2011, 02:22:58 UTC
- Beautiful coloring, great choice of background texture.
- Lovely job with the background replacement! The coloring also looks very good!
- The texture in the background complements the waves in her hair beautifully, and teh colors are lovely and soft. My focus goes right to her face. Well done!
- Lovely coloring and an overall gorgeous icon.
- beautiful colouring; I love the waves in the background.

Additional:
- I love the colouring you've done here, and the background replacement is wonderful.

Reply


xafirah March 26 2011, 11:30:05 UTC
Thank you =)
Comments for #2 please, unscreened is fine :)

Reply

shadowserenity March 27 2011, 02:24:35 UTC
- [Lovely crop and the colouring looks almost like it has been painted.]
- Great natural colouring; right amount of brightness and sharpness.
- That was a tough cap, but the background blends perfectly with his coloring, and focuses very nicely on his face. It just looks so happy :)

Additional:
- the colouring is lovely; such a happy icon!

Reply


trekkiemage March 26 2011, 13:49:00 UTC
Wow, was not expecting that! Thank you guys so much, all of the icons were wonderful this week <3

Could I get the comments for 8 please? Unscreened is fine:)

Reply

shadowserenity March 27 2011, 02:25:37 UTC
- Great crop and use of negative space. It's very similar to the other submitted icon made from the same screencap. I'm choosing this one because it more sharp, detailed.
- I love how intense the blue is without losing any of the detail of his face, and the background extension on the left is nicely executed.
- the use of purple is lovely; good crop.

Additional:
- Excellent colouring

Reply


blueleopard87 March 26 2011, 14:14:33 UTC
Comments for #6 please, unscreened is fine. :)

Reply

shadowserenity March 27 2011, 02:27:07 UTC
- [Wonderful crop - she looks as if she has so much purpose.]
- I really like the colouring and the subtle use of texture.
- All the icons in this round were so well executed, it was really hard to pick a LF. Your coloring and crop are incredible, and it would have been my favorite if it weren't for the line across the bottom of her hair. I know it's mostly the fault of the cap, but it looks like a poorly cut out texture - especially against the lovely red along the top half of the icon. If you had used the blur or clone tool to soften that line it would be perfect.

Additional:
- Great crop and use of color / light.
- very nice cropping; my only suggestion concerns removing the little line/box below her hair.

Reply


kibethsbark March 26 2011, 18:26:02 UTC
Could I have the comment for #3 please? Unscreened is fine :)

Reply

shadowserenity March 27 2011, 02:27:23 UTC
- The crop and the color adjustments you made look very good!

Reply


Leave a comment

Up