Round 3 // Challenge 10 Results

Apr 09, 2011 20:55

The votes are very close this week.

Challenge 10 Results )

round 3, challenge 10, results

Leave a comment

Comments 7

xafirah April 9 2011, 12:35:32 UTC
Comment for #3 please, unscreened is fine.

Reply

shadowserenity April 10 2011, 05:37:20 UTC
- Good concept but it somehow feels cluttered.

Reply


kibethsbark April 9 2011, 17:42:24 UTC
I'm surprised, but thank you! :D The voting was incredibly difficult this week.

Could I have the comments for #4? Unscreened is fine. :)

Reply

shadowserenity April 10 2011, 05:38:52 UTC
Congratulations! From what I've seen of next week's entries, it'll be very difficult again.

- Good crop, love the skin tone coloring.
- I like the rotation, but her shoulder is overly sharp and something about the image quality doesn't seem quite right.
-The coloring is soft and natural, the crop is great, and the sharpness is great (especially with the background). It's beautiful :)
- [excellent crop, depth created by lighting effects]

Reply


(The comment has been removed)

shadowserenity April 10 2011, 05:39:51 UTC
You know how much I love your icon ;).

- Lovely colors.
- This is rather nitpicky, but there doesn't seem to be quite enough contrast over her face (her nose blends into the rest of her features a lot). Other than that, though, I love the colouring and the brightness!
- STUNNING use of purple; I so want this icon to use after voting; love it.
- The background is lovely and I love the red in her earrings, but her skin is very washed out and has a slightly unnatural yellow tint to it. I could see it a little bit on my iPod, but on this monitor it's even more pronounced.

Reply


trekkiemage April 9 2011, 23:17:55 UTC
Doesn't surprise me - as soon as I saw how orange it looked I knew this was probably my week. It's been super fun though, I never expected to get this far! Especially with such amazing entries <3

Could I get my comments? Un-screened is fine :)

Reply

shadowserenity April 10 2011, 05:41:34 UTC
Sorry to see you go! Thanks so much for participating again :D.

- I really love the color tones and the softness of the icon, as well as the use of a light texture. So beautiful.
- Coloring is a bit dull, slightly too pink/red. The light effect on her face seems to be too strong.
- I like the textures, but the skin tone is a little too dark and slightly orange.
- too much orange shading; the white blob makes Kira lose her sharpness and clarity.
- Nice color, it could use a bit more contrast, but overall it's well-done.
- [odd lighting, white 'blur' thing in the middle is distracting]

Reply


Leave a comment

Up