Round 3 // Challenge 12 Results

[shadowserenity]

Thanks so much to everyone who answered my voting call! It was fantastic!

EDIT: Turns out somehow I misread a vote. Sorry, all! That means now the results have changed. No one could separate your icons after all.

ROUND OVER!

Comments

[xafirah]

Wow, scores are really close!
Congratulations to obaona and realproof. You both made incredibly beautiful icons. I didn't leave you any concrit to your icons - I didn't know what to write - they're all gorgeous and I love every single icon in the final challenge.
I'm not surprised people didn't want to vote - the choice was very difficult. But thank you so much for voting and concrit.

I'd be happy to read my comments, thank you.

And thank you for running this lims comm, shadowserenity. It was my first round and I enjoyed it! :D

[shadowserenity]

I'm happy to hear you enjoyed your first round! The quality of your entries was A+ :). Thanks for participating

[shadowserenity]

I somehow managed to miscount a vote and not pick up the error when I was rechecking, so I must apologise as that changes the result. While your votes don't change, one vote goes from obaona Seven of Nine icon to realproof's Deanna icon - which now means there's a three way tie for first place as everyone has a total of -3.

I do apologise again, but congratulations!

[realproof]

Congratulations obaona, your 7of9 icon was gorgeous! and similarly for xafirah, your B'elanna one was lovely. :)

thank you, Amsie for another lovely round of this.

[also, did you forget one positive vote for the remix icons? I only count 19 total *wanted to know how many votes there were in the end and counted everything*]

oh, and for once I'd like my comments, please

[shadowserenity]

Thank you for participating again! :D I really loved your Deanna icon for this challenge

[shadowserenity]

Unbelievably, I somehow managed to miscount and not pick up my error. I've corrected it now and we all have ties for first place!

Here's your corrected vote for Part 1, icon 3:
- Coloring is pretty and vivid without being overly bright, and the clarity is wonderful. Awesome crop!
- Fits the task and have great texture spots to ease the scene

[realproof]

lol, oh my. well, here's to us all! :)

[shadowserenity]

YAY, congratulations :D

[shadowserenity]

Gah, seems I miscounted a vote and gave you one more favourite vote for your Seven of Nine icon that there in fact was. While that doesn't change your ranking, it's now a tie between all participants.

Sorry for the mistake! But still - YAY, congrats! :)