Round 1: Challenge 3 | Voting

[genrelimsmod]

We had some lovely icons submitted this week, so on to the voting!

Four makers did not enter this week and have used a skip:
adriftingsea (0) - this was your last skip and therefore you are out, however you are invited to come back during the comeback rounds.
novindalf (1)          
sietepecados (1)  
setentpet (1)           

Comments

[lady_turner]

1 lesser quality:
#3 - The cutout is nicely done, but the overall composition looks kinda weird. The color block on the left seems a bit random, maybe putting more elements (or deleting this one) would have made the icon more interesting.

1 favorite:
#1

[setentpet]

1 lesser quality:
#3 - The icon could use a little more contrast to make her not so washed out and while the composition is interesting with the big border on the side it doesn't really add anything to the icon.

1 favorite:
#1 - (reason optional but nice) 

[alisea_dream]

1 lesser quality:
2 - The coloring is a bit too orange in my opinion. The animation is nice and interesting but I don't get how the petals gets behind her body but in front of her hair on the right.

1 favorite:
3

[ella_rose88]

1 lesser quality:
3 - The overall composition is great; however the colouring is a bit bland and could be improved on.

1 favorite:
1 - The colouring of the background and Claire is lovely and vibrant. The text works well with the background and overall I love the composition of the whole icon.