(Untitled)

Jul 17, 2005 16:04

I finished the 6th book last night and well... you'll see.

Some HBP questions and comments. )

Leave a comment

Comments 16

pandorassox July 17 2005, 20:29:27 UTC
My friend has a theory on Snape that I feel is quite illuminating. Some other people feel the same way, but I've got this link right here. It's the only way that it would really make sense to me; otherwise, Rowling's just undone too many of her themes and too much of her characterization.

The relatively sudden shippiness can probably be explained by the fact that they're all around sixteen now, and... yeah.

Reply

sunshineyjen July 17 2005, 20:58:19 UTC
Fantastic theory your friend has. And well written too!

Reply

pandorassox July 17 2005, 21:00:00 UTC
Thanks! I'll let her know.

Oh, I just have to believe it.

Reply

droolings July 17 2005, 22:09:38 UTC
I agree with your friend. This has been talked about a little bit and it's seems the most natural explanation. She goes even further with the love bond though, it's very interesting. Might be a reason my Dumbledore wanted to buried at Hogwarts. Would it mean Hogwarts would be a safe haven for Harry like the Dursley's once was? Interesting stuff. I loved this book.

Reply


gildedmuse July 17 2005, 20:43:32 UTC
And I would suppose that his Death Eaters would know about the horcruxes and so Regulus would fit the best.

I very much so doubt Voldemort told his Death Eaters about the horcruxes. In fact, *if* Snape were good he most likely would have known about them and told Dumbledore, therefore defeating the purposes of half of the lessons between him and Harry.

Reply


lily403 July 18 2005, 00:17:08 UTC
Remus/Tonks is not love. REMUS LOVES SIRIUS, DAMNIT.

*collapses into tears*

(Note that I cannot be held responsible for anything I've said. The grief that R/S was not confirmed is still too near. *faints*)

Reply

coconutsoup92 July 18 2005, 00:42:45 UTC
Well since Sirius is deceased (rest in peace my love) Tonks is the next best, no?

Reply

lily403 July 18 2005, 00:46:45 UTC
Of course. *sniffle* Tonks is the only female I could ever stand Remus being with. Ever.

But damnit, it's all so unfair. Sirius should come back from the veil, and they'll shag, and Voldemort will be so shocked he drops dead, and that will be the end of the seventh book.

Reply

freakycheri July 18 2005, 16:48:34 UTC
I suppose... Tonks sort of annoys me with her "Wotcher"s. Grr. Still, the poor wee werewolf needs some lovin'!

Can anyone figure out the age difference?

Reply


aoyana July 18 2005, 00:44:54 UTC
"...also a heavy locket that none of them could open" pg 116, OotP. A heavy locket that no one could open in Grimmuald place? R.A.B.? It fits to me :P

I liked the Horcruxes. They explained a lot.

Reply

freakycheri July 18 2005, 16:47:40 UTC
"...also a heavy locket that none of them could open" pg 116, OotP.

Ooooh - It MUST be!

Reply


jenniferjayde July 18 2005, 03:25:50 UTC
This is from my journal ( ... )

Reply

quite_grey July 18 2005, 04:21:15 UTC
Sorry, this was supposed to be a reply to you :)

Plus Dumbledore has a portrait, so they can still talk to him then, can't they?

I thought the same thing.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up