Comments | hbp_discuss: (без темы)

struggled_smile in hbp_discuss

(Untitled)

Jul 21, 2005 22:12

Theory: I believe Sirius Black to still be alive.

On pages 805-806 in The Order Of The Phoenix it states:

"Only a couple were still battling, apparently unaware of the new arrival. Harry saw Sirius duck Bellatrix's jet of red light: He was laughing at her. "Come on, you can do better than that!" he yelled, his voice echoing around the cavernous ( Read more... )

Comments 2

moshette_steph July 22 2005, 02:55:27 UTC

I don't think anyone has argued what you just said. It's generally believed that it wasn't the spell that killed Sirius, but the fact that he passed into the curtain.

Ditto on the person above me, but JRK ALSO said that the mirror Sirius gave Harry will come into play.

Yeah But caitlin45 July 25 2005, 04:08:03 UTC

Well yeah, it was just a stunning spell, but it doesn't matter cuz he's trappedi n limbo. So whetehr he's dead or stunned doesn't matter, he can't come out. At least that's what I thought.