I Believe in the Power of Myth: A Lord of the Rings and Supernatural credo

Jan 30, 2008 22:33



I believe in the stories we tell one another, whether it is across the flickering light of the evening's fire or by the glow upon a flat screen.  It is in this way that we name our fears, and give each other the gift of belief in something bigger than ourselves and the courage to face the darkness that crowds in behind our backs.

As the ( Read more... )

meta, lotr parallels

Leave a comment

Comments 29

jdsgirlbev January 31 2008, 04:05:00 UTC
ok...so you just made me cry like a big ol' baby. *sniffle*
And I just friended you.

Reply

hearseeno February 3 2008, 18:20:47 UTC
Awwwwww. That's okay. It made me *sniffle*, too, and I was the one writing it. :P

*friends you back*

Reply

jdsgirlbev February 3 2008, 19:47:57 UTC
oh thank heavens.... I do that to myself too!

Reply


zillah975 January 31 2008, 05:08:53 UTC
I love this post. LoTR was my first fandom, Boromir and Faramir my first fandom crush, and I maintain that LoTR and Supernatural have all the same wonderful things about them. I love them for almost exactly the same reasons.

Reply

hearseeno February 3 2008, 18:25:10 UTC
Thanks Zillah.

It turns out I owe you the introduction to SPN, as you were the one who hooked ErinRua into the fandom. She, in turn, turned me onto SPN. I've turned another friend onto it, who has passed it on to her partner, who turned her cousin and now the rest of her family onto it. I've lost track after that. So, in effect, you're a fandom great-great-great-great grandmother. :D

Reply


bowtrunckle January 31 2008, 06:42:56 UTC
*claps*

Such lovely words! Amen to your creed. That, my friend, is the power of fiction. Well done stories that inspire will never go out of style if they be told in a visual medium or in the more traditional written format (unlike say ... reality TV (pssst, someone tell CW this!)).

I enjoyed the parallels you drew. The role of women in romantic roles as the mysterious, virtually inaccessible ideal in both LotR and SPN is something I've always found interesting (hello, ivory tower meet the pedestal). The estrangement from romantic love seems to be a commonality in most war epics.

Reply

hearseeno February 3 2008, 18:32:15 UTC
Thanks BT. :)

That, my friend, is the power of fiction

Yep yep!

The role of women in romantic roles as the mysterious, virtually inaccessible ideal in both LotR and SPN is something I've always found interesting (hello, ivory tower meet the pedestal).

Yeah, we seem to be getting a bit of the whole madonna-whore dicotomy in SPN.

Reply


sadelyrate January 31 2008, 09:19:20 UTC
This made my heart ache. As well as remind me that it's been ages since I last watched LotR. And it was so very, very good, overall. Though I have to admit I never realized before just how similar Brothers -Mir are to Brothers Winchester...

*is idly wondering all the similarities between Supernatural and The Witcher*

Thank you.

Reply

hearseeno February 3 2008, 18:39:58 UTC
*is idly wondering all the similarities between Supernatural and The Witcher*

Do it! Do it! Do it! *g*

never realized before just how similar Brothers -Mir are to Brothers Winchester

You know, when you say it just like that you're making my brain *whirl* yet again. Definitely a LOT of parallels, all the way from losing their mother at an early age, a father who demanded them to be warriors to meet his needs to protect what he loved, how the older brother protects the younger brother and acts as mediator between father and second-born son, a second-born son who despaired of pleasing his father, etc.etc.etc. :D Hmmmm...

LOL! You always do that to me. You know, I miss your Tiny Trifles because of that. You were constantly picking out observations I'd missed that would send me off happily cogitating.

Reply

bowtrunckle February 3 2008, 18:49:41 UTC
I miss your Tiny Trifles

Ditto. *smiles*

Reply

sadelyrate February 3 2008, 20:30:20 UTC
There are definitely parallels between the LotR-brothers and the Spn-brothers. Eerily so. I wonder if they will increase; what with Dean's deal, it's certainly possible that the elder brother's gonna get it... but will the younger almost get burned? *thinky*

Ah, Tiny Trifles... I sort of fell out of that, and have been meaning to pick them up again. I've still got more than half of the Second Season to go through, anyway...
I'll promise to try and finish them some time in the future, 'kay? :)

Soon as I've gathered enough visual aids, I'll show you just why Geralt of Rivia and his world have stolen my heart and made me curse the fact that I can read Polish about as well as a mouse can use a bicycle...;)
It's like Supernatural set in a sword'n'sorcery-setting!
Save that there's no Impala, really. But Geralt does have a horse in the books...*thinkety-think*

Reply


yourlibrarian January 31 2008, 21:33:55 UTC
Great post. And I had to laugh at the reluctant heroes part -- what is WITH the choking? Sam's windpipe should have collapsed by now!

Reply

hearseeno February 3 2008, 18:42:08 UTC
Thanks yourlibrarian. :)

what is WITH the choking?

*snerk* I dunnnnnno. LOL I'm tempted to wonder if SOMEone on the writing staff has something of a kink. :P

Reply


Leave a comment

Up