critique, please!

Mar 10, 2008 19:03




Read more... )

Leave a comment

Comments 8

meupatdoes March 11 2008, 00:01:50 UTC
I agree that his shoulder is a little bit (emphasis on little bit) upright and would like to see his neck tie in a smidge higher.

But these are small quibbles for what seems to me to be a conformationally sound, quality horse.

Enjoy him, he is lovely!

Reply

k7point5 March 11 2008, 00:04:15 UTC
Ok thanks. When you say his neck could tie in a bit higher, do you mean at the withers or at the chest?

Reply

meupatdoes March 11 2008, 00:32:22 UTC
At the chest.

(But only a smidge.)

:)

Reply

k7point5 March 11 2008, 15:07:12 UTC
I had a sense of that. Sometimes when Fugly mentions "nests" I wonder if that's what she's talking about. When he shapes up in the summer it gets a bit better but I guess if that's the most major thing, I can deal with it! I still think he's gorgeous haha. Thanks for your input :)

Reply


shira March 11 2008, 00:20:24 UTC
Actually, there are a number of minor things besides the heels; capped elbow, too-straight shoulder, neck is too short for the rest of him, and upside down. That may improve with work, but you can still see the tendency for the neck to be upside down (due to the huge wither) even in the trotting pic, where he is obviously better muscled. He looks like he does not have a very long gait, but perhaps it's just how he looks in that one pic. Hindquarter is nice though.

Reply

k7point5 March 11 2008, 03:01:50 UTC
Yeah he does have very large withers, and that seems to be the root of a lot of his conformational issues. Those are some really good points (thanks!). I didn't even know "capped elbow" is a conformational fault.

I don't see what you mean by he doesn't have a very long gait...he is tracking up in this photo and he usually over tracks, much to the dismay of our farrier who keeps having to put his front shoes back on!

I've dug up a few more trotting photos where he's moving out:


... )

Reply


blitzen_ March 11 2008, 12:55:34 UTC
his heels stood out to me too, before i read your critique.

Reply

k7point5 March 11 2008, 13:24:52 UTC
they are very frustrating. he has horrible feet all around. we've put him on $50/tub hoof supplements, used hoof conditioners twice daily, and had the farrier pull every trick in the book to make them grow but they really don't grow at all.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up