Snape and Sirius

[coppertop1]

Cut: An analysis of Severus Snape and Sirius Black

Comments

sorry, I'm not a member of the community but I'm an HP fan

[keshichan]

I think that you have good point (or points, taking into consideration that you talked about Black and Snape). I really think that Sirius was too serious in the past that he became bitter towards a lot of things.
Well, I imagine that it was really hard for Snape to let go of his bitterness regarding the whole Lily and James story. But I guess, even though he hated the part wherein he had to save and help Harry, being the son of James, his love for Lily was overwhelming.
Am I blabbing too much? Sorry about that. But, all in all, I loved your explanation.

[luvtheheaven]

I really love this post... and the comments. So interesting. I pretty much agree with all of the points made, and I love being reminded of so much specific stuff from the books. ;) I never read too much HP fanfiction about either of these characters, but now I want to read more!

[coppertop1]

I haven't read much fanfiction but I've seen some good ones. I love the Marauders era, and I did have a L/J fic but it fizzled. Snape and Sirius are mirror images of each other. They're both equally guilty

[tatgoat]

I like your points but there is something you missed.... If Snape had died Remus wouldn't have lived with the guilt, even in Azkaban, he would have gotten executed by the ministry, as it was the law about werewolfs attacking humans...