Comments | hudgens_lims: Round 3, Challenge 4 Voting

chewyyyyyy in hudgens_lims

Round 3, Challenge 4 Voting

Mar 27, 2010 18:42

Skipping:
06. minutesto12
08. one_sweetlove
10. hsmlove_x

Disqualified:
04. twothirdstrio

( Voting for Challenge 4 )

! voting, ! round: 01, - challenge 4

Comments 5

chewyyyyyy March 27 2010, 10:43:36 UTC

PS: Participants who entered this challenge are not allowed to vote.

lalonde March 27 2010, 16:39:05 UTC

VOTING OFF:
#01: Too brown and over sharpened

FAVOURITE:
#03: Good colouring.

oneoffour111 March 31 2010, 16:44:28 UTC

VOTING OFF:
#01: Coloring is unflattering, Vanessa is relegated to a small, small part of the icon, and the textures are distracting. Puzzling, too--I can't actually tell what they are, or what they have to do with Vanessa's bit.

FAVOURITE:
#02: Simple and elegant, this makes Vanessa pop. The lines are beautiful. Great job!

vapor April 3 2010, 21:14:35 UTC

VOTING OFF:
#03: Icon is too oversharpened.

FAVOURITE:
#02: Nice soft coloring and good crop.

Can you return the vote here at keira_lims please?

glimmerless April 4 2010, 06:58:20 UTC

VOTING OFF:
#03: Icon is oversharpened.

FAVOURITE:
#02: Nice simple yet effective icon composition and colouring.

vote please? http://community.livejournal.com/saoirselims/7334.html =]