American Idol - Top 36 Week 1

[hylandr]

Here's what I thought of the first group of 12. These were the notes I made as they were performing, not anything overly fleshed out.

Comments

[boysnightout82]

really Brent Keith as the third. I know we can do it based on what we might think but overall America will never but him through especially based on that country song IMHO.

[hylandr]

You never know. There have been a few country singers that went pretty far int he competition and weren't have as good of singers as him.