People's Favorites

[mellie]

Challenge 1 Challenge 2 Challenge 3

Comments

[miz_lou]

... well, there are benefits to both public and private critiques.

I think making them public would encourage well rounded critiques while the publication of them would let others know that we are a serious group in our intent of icon making.

However, taking critiques of your work is quite difficult... even if it is well rounded.

I'm really ok with either way

[got_no_strings]

Ummm, I picked private - only because I cannot give a good critique *blush*
I only see the good points in other's works so I can only tell them what I like about it instead of what they need to improve on.

*shrug* publc or private - either way suits me fine.

[miz_lou]

Did we ever need to submit our critiques public or privately? Never saw a post for it, but have them saved on the lappie.