The Good Critique Check list: [] Is my critique easy to understand? [] Are my reasons based on technical mechanics and not personal opinion? [] Have I told the applicant why their icons aren't technically sound? [] Have I been specific? [] Have I also told the applicant what they're doing correctly? [] Have I pointed the applicant toward sources of inspiration and/or useful resources that they can use to make what they're already doing better? [] Have I used adjectives or nouns that could be insulting? (i.e bad, awful, ugly, wrong, etc.) [] Have I avoided phasing that could be easily perceived as condescending, judgmental, or arrogant (i.e 'The way I do it is the only correct way')?
The Good Critique Check list:
[] Is my critique easy to understand?
[] Are my reasons based on technical mechanics and not personal opinion?
[] Have I told the applicant why their icons aren't technically sound?
[] Have I been specific?
[] Have I also told the applicant what they're doing correctly?
[] Have I pointed the applicant toward sources of inspiration and/or useful resources that they can use to make what they're already doing better?
[] Have I used adjectives or nouns that could be insulting? (i.e bad, awful, ugly, wrong, etc.)
[] Have I avoided phasing that could be easily perceived as condescending, judgmental, or arrogant (i.e 'The way I do it is the only correct way')?
Reply
Leave a comment