01 - The coloring is really great and the icon is well executes, but the tiny text makes the icon look less clean. A better word could also have been chosen, as the focus of the image is not the butterfly.
positive feedback 02 - I love the grey and grungy shading in this icon! It adds a sense of depth almost like you are looking down on Kikyou.
03 - I don't like the tint of green and yellow in this icon. I think that the text is really stylish, but a little too big. It takes the focus away from Kagome a little too much. The crop is great though!
3 - The crop seems awkward and the text overpowering. Maybe not cropping right over the edge of Kagome's eye and/or making the text a little smaller in proportion to how much of the character is shown would balance it out.
Least favorite: #2 - While I think the way the text is done looks cool, the image is boring and as I can't make out Kikyou's face, it fails to convey any emotion.
Other comments: I really like the other two. Inuyasha looks so cute in #1 and the coloring in #3 is amazing.
3 - It seems as if the icon lacked emotion at the first sight and it could be a bit brighter; maybe changing the font and adding some brushes could help to make the icon more lively.
Comments 7
positive feedback
02 - I love the grey and grungy shading in this icon! It adds a sense of depth almost like you are looking down on Kikyou.
Reply
Reply
Reply
Other comments:
I really like the other two. Inuyasha looks so cute in #1 and the coloring in #3 is amazing.
Reply
Reply
Leave a comment