Round 24: Week 2 Voting

[rhye]

Comments

[rhye]

These are all really gorgeous!

05 - I think this one shows the least creativity and displays the least technical proficiency. Sadly, neither icon makes much sense without the other. Together, though, they make a great pair. Some light textures might have spruced them up a bit, and maybe some unique coloring as well.

----

I adore 03 so much. The colors are just fantastic and artistic.

[farsketched]

set 5: The stark black background just seems really overpowering. The images themselves could probably pop more with more contrast.

[carnimirie]

Least Favorite Pair: 5A&B
Reason: The concept behind this icon is nice, I especially like the image chosen for the pair. However the thing with icon pairs is they need to both appear as a viable pair and function on their own, because an icon can only be used individually. The text on the pair doesn't make sense when the icons stand on their own. Also, the font and coloring of the text doesn't match the feel of the rest of the icon.

[dechanter]

Least Favorite: 5 A & B
The text seems to take away from the icons, standing alone the 5A wouldn't make too much sense since it just says 'never' over Inuyasha. Though, I do like the simplicity.

I loved 1A & 1B, whoever did those did a great job.

[wockys]

4A and B - The coloring on these icons is a bit strange and doesn't really add to the icons or make them stand out as especially interesting :(