race post/rant

Feb 15, 2010 17:52

Do people recognize at all that Persia is a real place? That it's still in existence under a different name full of real people that are largely not white and of whom America largely isn't a real big fan?

If there were a prince of Persia, he would look like this:

Read more... )

Leave a comment

Comments 4

narcolepticcat February 16 2010, 01:55:55 UTC
to the part of this that is rant: u go girl.

to the part of this that is post (and therefore, i hope, means open to discussion, and if not open to discussion then skip to the p.s.): should, then, gay characters or disabled characters in the media only be portrayed by gay actors or disabled actors? because if that were so, the amount of gay or disabled actors willing to play the limited range of gay or disabled stereotypes would quickly dwindle to few if not none... right?

we really really don't live in a post-minority culture in terms of opportunities for minorities or representations of them.

p.s. why has not i seen post from you in while, or do i just imagine i haven't seen a post? Thank you for giving me something to think/feel about this evening other than how tired i am and how much my back feels like deaaaaath.

Reply

jaeliyah February 16 2010, 21:06:42 UTC
This is a good point and exactly where the topic gets squishy. Because in a perfect world, everyone would be able to try out for every part, and the best actor would win, and makeup and props would be able to take care of the rest. The folly in my argument is that I have no actual evidence to back up suspicions that people of Iranian descent were not approached or pursued to the degree that I imagine Jake Gyllenhaal was.

So take Abigail Breslin in The Miracle Worker. I don't know that anyone knows how well or poorly she can affect blindness or deafness, but the complaints are that no blind or deaf actors were given the opportunity to audition. So it's one of those things where the main running assumption is automatically that "normal" people can do it best. So in the way that minority characters weren't considered to play the speaking characters in Harry Potter but for the roles that specifically call for them or in Lord of the Rings, it seems fair to consider people of Iranian descent or at least prioritize them for roles that ( ... )

Reply


horatio09 February 16 2010, 20:35:26 UTC
**cough**Last Airbender Movie**cough cough**

Reply

jaeliyah February 16 2010, 21:07:55 UTC
TOTES!!

Reply


Leave a comment

Up