In response to a discussion I had tonight

Sep 07, 2007 04:15

What is your first thought when you see this image?


Read more... )

questions

Leave a comment

Comments 17

lifebytes_yaya September 7 2007, 10:47:05 UTC
the first thought i thought of was "noose!" and then after that i thought of suicide.... then i thought of the movie "dancer in the dark"

if it was in a workplace i think it would put pressure on people
like
"if you don't work hard you'll get fired and die!"
but not really die, but you know what i mean

in public? i would assume it just meant "we're all going to die soon....?"

but i'm just guessing on both of those

Reply

reverend_cary32 September 7 2007, 14:38:51 UTC
Oooo...I LOVE Dancer in the Dark (one of my favs!!). Gold stars for the reference.

Reply

lifebytes_yaya September 7 2007, 20:02:29 UTC
yay! i love it too, i recently made my mom watch it :]

Reply


quitereasonable September 7 2007, 12:12:48 UTC
My first thought was of suicide, but if I saw it in public, I would likely think it was a threat or the setup for a movie. The color of the noose is wrong in my head for some reason - is that weird? It just looks too happy to be a good noose.

Reply

janejellyroll September 7 2007, 19:48:58 UTC
I think the color is off because it's that cheapo synthetic rope.

Reply


hunterxtc September 7 2007, 12:30:15 UTC
I thought of "The South" and a lynchin' goin' on!

Reply

janejellyroll September 7 2007, 19:48:32 UTC
Once again, you and I are of a like mind. And apparently the only ones.

Reply

hunterxtc September 8 2007, 15:10:34 UTC
Ahhh well, if I had to pick a mind to be like, yours is at the top of my list...

I'm interested in what brought on this post. I mean, I was brought up seeing pictures of Emmitt Till and various hate crimes against black people in the south. Stuff like this is one of the reasons why I have that phobia about "The South". I am pretty sure stuff like this no longer happens, but these images are etched in my head.

Reply

janejellyroll September 11 2007, 23:42:14 UTC
There was recently a situation near Memphis where some community theatre employees (apparently all white) tied some ropes backstage into nooses. A black employee came in the next day, saw them, and complained. The three employees were fired for what they're describing as a harmless, non-racial goof-off.

When my husband and I were discussing it, he saw it as a non-racial matter and thought the black employee was reading too much into it. I contended that if I saw a noose in my work area, my first thought would be something racial as well. So I posted it on here to see what people think. Based on the responses to this entry, I think it's something more like white people have the "luxury" of not associating nooses with lynching. It isn't something that we have to think about if we don't want to. I think that the noose is a pretty clear symbol to black people in the South (and across America).

Reply


redheap September 7 2007, 12:31:29 UTC
Suicide, and friends who've done so.

I'd see it as a cry for help.

Reply


rickysbaby September 7 2007, 14:00:38 UTC
I guess "yippee!" is the wrong answer??

Reply

janejellyroll September 7 2007, 19:49:32 UTC
Haha.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up