Results Challenge # 5 Session Two

[tout_moi]

Hello everybody! Finally we have results challenge # 5.
Thanks for your votes!
This time we have one eliminated and one winner.

Eliminated:


lapine29

Thanks for participation! Hope to see you next session!

People's choice:


xtess

Congrats!!!

Banner

No Mod's choice.

Results:
1. - - / +
2. +
3. - - - - -/ +
4. - / + + + + + +
5. - -

Reasons:
negative:
# 1
- the white brush/texture thing is really distracting
- tiny text or something at the icon, looking soooo bad.
# 3
- double image doesn't fit
- i like their attempt at making a really great icon, but i feel the others stand out more then this one.
- the repeated images aren't strong enough, they look too blurred
- Coloring is to pale and it looks like her hair is red, and that doesn't look good.
- coluring looks pale and icon is blurry.
# 4
- oversharpened
# 5
- The image is grainy and the tiny text box doesn't do anything extra.
- Icon looks too grainy and a bit blurry.
positive:
# 1
- great coloring and texture use
# 2
- Duplicating works very well, and text fits in great.
# 3
- I really like the blending and colouring
# 4
- amazing crop and textures use
- i really like the spotlight effect of this icon, and the coloring works very well. :)
- It's a bit dark but the fading's nice.
- the icon just amazing, color & texture are well combined.
- lovely colouring
- Great use of texture!
- love composition and textures used. colouring is amazing!