Season 3 episode 10 rant

[katrushkalupin]

Soooooo, after watching that episode it occurred to me that the writers of this show have A) no clue of how lineages were passed on, B) quite possibly made Robin even more annoying when he was little then when he grew up, and C)obviously do not keep track of previous episodes before writing new ones

Comments

[mrs_tubbs]

RA said in interviews that there was a deleted scene in Season 1 that referred to Robin and Guy having known each other as children. Bet the producers are kicking themselves for deleting it now

[katrushkalupin]

But this is where it get's confusing. The entail in P&P is passed from male to male. I cannot imagine that Sir Malcom, considering the the time he was living in, was like "Ok here's this living, but if you die your family is screwed even if you have a son and heir." It just doesn't make sense. Cause the reason he was negotiating with Gislean was that he and her were getting married and once that happened her husbands lands would go back to him (Malcolm) as he would then be her husband. Since since he already had a son, (Robin) there was a likelihood that Guy wouldn't get anything because he wasn't Malcolm blood son, merely his step-son. That was why Gislean was like "The lands have to go to Guy."
This show is like a train wreck but i can't stop watching, lol. Bring on episode 12 baby!!!

[mrs_tubbs]

It was the best I could do ;)

It is hideously compulsive viewing. :)

[gizxmaz]

I totally agree with you about everything, option C is so true. What the hell.. What did the writers think?

[shy_nerthuserce]

Wordy, wordy, wordy, word!! :¬( And the comments to your post? Yup, agreeing with all of those, too! :¬}