(Untitled)

Sep 23, 2004 00:16

I have a question for you Fic Writers out there. Please give it a read and see if I'm just weird or what. Shut up. I heard the snickering.

Read more... )

Leave a comment

Comments 20

(The comment has been removed)

kenyacandoit September 22 2004, 22:01:23 UTC
It's at her website, though she does have a link at the end of each chapter that says "send feedback to hername".

Eh, I doubt I'd say anything. I mean, I never do! So why start now, especially when I still loved the story and will continue to read everything she writes?

Thanks for commenting, though. It's nice to know my post didn't just go out into a void. I needed that. :)

Reply


nwhepcat September 22 2004, 23:01:12 UTC
Knowing me, I might not comment on that either, though it would sure bug the piss out of me. Especially if it were a finished work.

I have used repetition, though most of the time I like to think I know I'm doing it and am making a choice. Though sometimes it's because I can't think of anything better.

Reply

kenyacandoit September 23 2004, 20:04:35 UTC
Thanks for replying. Yeah, I'm already over it. :) Or at least until I read that particular story again!

Reply


vampirefever September 23 2004, 02:07:41 UTC
When I write and I notice a repetition of a word in adjoining sentences/paragraphs, I do everything I can to change one of them. So I know how annoying read a frequent repetition can be.

When I post stuff, I appreciate comments telling me something doesn't work, but I'm like you, and would find it totally arrogant to tell someone else (or be afraid to upset them).

Reply

kenyacandoit September 23 2004, 20:07:46 UTC
And far be it from me to be arrogant! ::nose in air:: :D

I've decided not to say anything. It's not like it's a life or death problem. Plus, I'm a chicken. :P

Reply


yin_again September 23 2004, 04:12:49 UTC
I'd want it pointed out.

Is it me?

/paranoia

Seriously, I know that I sometimes repeat words or phrases and don't notice until way later, when I read back after I've gotten some distance from the story. That said, people are touchy about their writing. If you know or strongly suspect that this person is open to constructive criticism, I'd go for it.

Reply

kenyacandoit September 23 2004, 20:11:13 UTC
Yes, it *is* you! NOT!!! Not that I'd be any more inclined to tell you as I am this other person, though. :D

I'm not going to say anything. It's really not the big deal my loooong post made it out to be. I do hope that someone(s) on my FL will read it and feel the same, though, so that I feel a bit vindicated!

Thanks for commenting.

Reply


spikedluv September 23 2004, 08:02:47 UTC
Yes, tell me! I try really hard not to use the same words over and over, especially when it's a word that isn't common, and I'd like to know if I missed something. I'd really like to know about it if it's jarring you out of the rhythm of the story, 'cause it's probably not just you.

Also, I have the same problem with reading something that jars me. I'm reading one author now who uses dashes for emphasis, which is annoying in itself, but even worse is the fact that the words she's emphasizing are the wrong words, at least in my opinion. I've had to stop reading her dashes as emphasis, but it's still annoying when I come across them, and they're in. Every. Paragraph!

Reply

kenyacandoit September 23 2004, 20:14:40 UTC
Yeah, don't you just --hate-- that? :D

I almost wished it was one of your stories, since you seem so open to this kind of critical fb. But alas, you are too perfect for me to do so!

Thanks so much for weighing in on this subject.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up