The Angels Take Manhattan review/thoughts

[kilodalton]

This was really full of plotholes.

[Spoiler (click to open)]

1) ... so, if "an image of an angel becomes an angel," then shouldn't the detective have been zapped back in time almost as soon as he stepped into the elevator with the poster of the Statue of Liberty? (Or gotten his neck broken/sand in his eye or something?) And since angels can turn other statues into angels,

Comments

[silverlunarstar]

Just saw s7 a few minutes ago... I think my Amy icon says it all.

Basically, I agree with all your points. Moffat can't leave fast enough.

This just in... a Moffat ep with no internal logic! News at eleven.

[spicandspan89]

Yeah the whole "time can be rewritten - except when it can't LOL" is very tiresome.

Also, River once made a freaking Dalek beg for mercy. And now she breaks HER wrist to free herself from an Angel? Why not just take a sledgehammer to the thing IDGI.

[ilsiux]

Unfff I agree so much with you ! you read my mind and put my thoughts on this page :D

[annissag]

So far I've enjoyed S7 more than S5 and waaaaaay more than S6. That said, I would have been more affected by Amy's departure if I'd been able to connect to her on an emotional level. She never felt fully fleshed out and always seemed like a cardboard place holder. As it is, I merely shrugged when she got zapped.

Bring on the new companion!

[jaggedshards]

I agree and disagree with your points - for example, I agree that everyone took their eyes off of the Angels too much, and considering that there were that many Angels in the vicinity I wonder why the Doctor, River, Amy and Rory had a such an easy time escaping the hotel. But then I could be wrong