THESTRALS! I forgot to mention them. They were EXACTLY how I imagined them (unlike the Portal of Doom). On the Ginny front...indeed! Why won't they let Ginny be awesome?
this is Nikki
anonymous
July 17 2007, 23:44:52 UTC
Overall, I thought this was a great movie, but too stylized for the Harry Potter series. It needed to stick to the books better because too many movie viewers have read and loved the books.
I was very unhappy about the handling of the prophecy. Nobody is supposed to hear it before it's demolished! Then Dumbledore admits that he heard it FROM TRELAWNEY (thus legitimizing her place at Hogwarts). And I agree with you that the convo regarding the prophecy is just as important (or more so) as the prophecy itself.
I feel sorry for the people who haven't read the book because so much was skipped in the movie that helped shape the story for books 5 and 6.
Comments 2
(The comment has been removed)
Reply
I was very unhappy about the handling of the prophecy. Nobody is supposed to hear it before it's demolished! Then Dumbledore admits that he heard it FROM TRELAWNEY (thus legitimizing her place at Hogwarts). And I agree with you that the convo regarding the prophecy is just as important (or more so) as the prophecy itself.
I feel sorry for the people who haven't read the book because so much was skipped in the movie that helped shape the story for books 5 and 6.
~Nikki
P.S. I MISS YOU!!!!!!!!!!
Reply
Leave a comment