Stumbled upon these videos on youtube:
Click to view
Atif's live performance:
Click to view
Clearly Atif is struggling to sing, he loses the "sur" at 0.08 (a little) again at 0.58 after this he is completely struggling for breath.... at 2.02 Atif is way off pitch. If ordinary people like me can notice it .... Abijeet's reaction is not a surprise.