Comments | lackofsatin: 3 questions for my JA Film & Lit class

lackofsatin

3 questions for my JA Film & Lit class

Feb 08, 2006 20:20

1. Why does Darcy not defend himself immediately, when Elizabeth accuses him of being unjust to Wickham? Why is his explanation in a letter? Letters cannot reveal subtle clues to character such as facial expression, tone, stance, etc. Based on the proposal scene, why would Darcy choose to express himself with words alone ( Read more... )

Comments 2

pinque February 9 2006, 03:02:04 UTC

I personally find it easier to confront an injustice in the written word. Speaking immediately after an injustice has been done to me or a friend or family member usually results in a lot of emotion and focus on hurt feelings rather than the facts ( ... )

lackofsatin February 10 2006, 02:23:21 UTC

Brilliant! Want to come to class with me ? :)

I agree with you about the restraint, also, he was pretty shocked at her rejection still. American young adults have been brought up that if you don't show every single emotion on your face and express it immediatly, you are not being 'honest.' This is shown really well in these scenes- the way spirited Lizzy addresses the rejected Mr. Darcy would have been seen as anything but disinterested for an early 1800's reader.

They also thought it was cruel to make Lydia marry Wickham. Like, why couldn't she just run off with him? Who cares? Again, totally missing the whole, you know, family ruination thing and all.