Round 5 // Challenge 2 Results

[shadowserenity]

Members' Choice and Mod's Choice winner banner maker for this challenge is alyburns.

Comments

[shadowserenity]

- [Oddly enough, I really like the starkness of this icon. It seems to capture, like, the entire first season for me.]
- The crop on Elizabeth is nice and I love the blue coloring.

[jhava]

Comments for 21 please. Unscreened is fine. Thank you!

[shadowserenity]

- Love the composition, with the central "triangle" formed by their heads. Great use of light and shade within the icon to direct our gaze. Lovely colour choices.
- [the lightening is making the icon blurry]

[wickedvengeance]

#27 please, unscreened is fine.

[shadowserenity]

- The text is distracting, the individual people aren't enough of a counterbalance.

Shoot, I'm in the middle of a charity

[alyburns]

auction and don't have the availability to do the banners - is there someone else who can take it this round?

Re: Shoot, I'm in the middle of a charity

[shadowserenity]

I've put the word out :).

[prone_tastic]

Thank you ! Comments for #8, please. Unscreened is fine. :)

[shadowserenity]

- interesting crop and blend of the image, and great texture usage.
- Gorgeous coloring and beautiful use of texture; John and Rodney are also beautifully blended into the picture.
- [I really like the colorisation and the texture]
- I love the bright colors and the balance of the icon.
- [Good overlaying of textures. Very pretty.]