- fantastic work on the background, she really seems to be part of it. The use of light is also great, it looks like sunbeams. - [i love the image of the stargate and the sky texture for the background, it really all comes together and i love how it is black and white, i feel that color would have overdone the icon] - black and white isn't contrasted enough. - Nice use of b&w as well as texture. - great black + white tones + central composition - I really like the blending of the three different images, they work quite well together and present a nice composition for the overall icon.
- Terrific composition! Great sense of motion, good colors, interesting background with the screen of Teyla. - great coloring and use of texture. - Little blurry. - while rodney appears a bit blurry, the use of the monitor image in the background works wonderfully.
- [The cut outs of John are overly sharp seeming and its too busy] - The contrast is too high on the character(s) and there's some pixelation around the edges. Good composition and background. - Both images are too sharp, the outline of the smaller isn't clean and too jagged. - very creative but needs additional contrast in the b&W to see any detail - The bold yellow background doesn't flow very well with the b&w, its a little distracting. - the black + white contrast is too high, making him appear oversharpened, interesting composition though - the background colour is too loud, the image of John too sharpened. - The images of John are over-sharpened and the yellow background is just too overbearing. - very, very sharp; I think the contrast is a bit too strong.
- my favourite icon for this challenge; the colours are perfect, as is the framing and blending. - the colouring is just perfect, the background texture really flatters the icon. - love the green, and each character is well isolated and put into the new background. - great design - ships that pass in the night - [I like how they merged Weir and McKay, the background is very soft and suits the icon perfectly]
Comments 11
Can I please see the comments for #2, please? Unscreened is fine.
Reply
- [i love the image of the stargate and the sky texture for the background, it really all comes together and i love how it is black and white, i feel that color would have overdone the icon]
- black and white isn't contrasted enough.
- Nice use of b&w as well as texture.
- great black + white tones + central composition
- I really like the blending of the three different images, they work quite well together and present a nice composition for the overall icon.
Reply
Reply
Reply
- great coloring and use of texture.
- Little blurry.
- while rodney appears a bit blurry, the use of the monitor image in the background works wonderfully.
Reply
Can I see the comments for #1?
Reply
- The contrast is too high on the character(s) and there's some pixelation around the edges. Good composition and background.
- Both images are too sharp, the outline of the smaller isn't clean and too jagged.
- very creative but needs additional contrast in the b&W to see any detail
- The bold yellow background doesn't flow very well with the b&w, its a little distracting.
- the black + white contrast is too high, making him appear oversharpened, interesting composition though
- the background colour is too loud, the image of John too sharpened.
- The images of John are over-sharpened and the yellow background is just too overbearing.
- very, very sharp; I think the contrast is a bit too strong.
Reply
Comments on #6 would be great, unscreened fine :D
Reply
- the colouring is just perfect, the background texture really flatters the icon.
- love the green, and each character is well isolated and put into the new background.
- great design - ships that pass in the night
- [I like how they merged Weir and McKay, the background is very soft and suits the icon perfectly]
Reply
Leave a comment