#1: - [Seems sharp, and the background doesn't feel well blended with Weir] - While I like the general concept of the icon,Elizabeth doesn't blend with the background and looks "put on top". There's too much difference between her colors and those in the background to make it look real. - [amazing color and cropping/added background] - The face is too blurry compared to the rest of the icon.
#5: - I love how you've reduced them to shadows; interesting choice :). - Figures are either too dark or not dark enough. - [i love how mckay and sheppard are dark with the light blue background, its very artsy and works very well] - blurry with no detail - interesting though - I absolutely adore the take on the cap in this icon, the choice to use only the silhouettes. It's simply gorgeous and very original. - Rodney and John are too dark and barely recognizable. - [Nice concept, but unfortunately you can even really tell who is in the icon or what it's from] - the black looks too saturated.
No problems :). Thanks so much for participating! SGA icon interest just seems to be... dying down now, so it was great to have many of the original participants back for one last time
( ... )
Comments 4
Congrats to crystal_lily and quiddity, good luck to you both!
Comments on #1 and 5, unscreened is fine :D
Reply
#1:
- [Seems sharp, and the background doesn't feel well blended with Weir]
- While I like the general concept of the icon,Elizabeth doesn't blend with the background and looks "put on top". There's too much difference between her colors and those in the background to make it look real.
- [amazing color and cropping/added background]
- The face is too blurry compared to the rest of the icon.
#5:
- I love how you've reduced them to shadows; interesting choice :).
- Figures are either too dark or not dark enough.
- [i love how mckay and sheppard are dark with the light blue background, its very artsy and works very well]
- blurry with no detail - interesting though
- I absolutely adore the take on the cap in this icon, the choice to use only the silhouettes. It's simply gorgeous and very original.
- Rodney and John are too dark and barely recognizable.
- [Nice concept, but unfortunately you can even really tell who is in the icon or what it's from]
- the black looks too saturated.
Reply
I'd like my comments for #3 and 7, please, unscreened. My apologies for being so late, I somehow missed this post.
Reply
Reply
Leave a comment