(Untitled)

Mar 26, 2005 03:48

As livingfossilcited me in his response to the final question, I felt somewhat compelled to answer. My responses may prove somewhat different from the usual, however, since I trade more in philosophy than in literature. Let's see, shall we?

You're stuck inside Farenheit 451, which book do you want to be?

Martin Heidegger's Being and Time because therein ( Read more... )

Leave a comment

Comments 6

niveau March 26 2005, 04:48:14 UTC
Husserl as a thinker is a great read, but as an author he is terrible! The translations by Moran seem to have been the best I've come across.

Reply

leafofgrass March 26 2005, 15:16:47 UTC
Oh, I agree, but those are some BIG books! I'm sure that the two volume set would keep me busy for QUITE some time, mining those pages for hidden nuances that only someone with too much time and nothing else to read can put into a text.

I haven't spent any time actually comparing the translations (in fact, I was unaware that there was more than one translator of Logical Investigations, but I have found in lookin at the German that most translators suffer from "I'm going to make this more technical than it has to be syndrome." This does not contribute to readablitiy, obviously! Also, I've found that some serious complications arise in that Husser makes some distinctions in German words that get translated as the same word into English (e.g. Gefülen and Empfinden). I guess this is why they make us learn languages to get the ol' PhD, eh?

Reply

niveau March 26 2005, 16:10:29 UTC
Or, at the very least, learn a way to further our hermeneutics of understanding.

Reply


29usc151 March 26 2005, 07:18:19 UTC
I'll jump on this when I'm back in town on Monday.

Reply

leafofgrass March 26 2005, 15:17:14 UTC
Righteous, yo!

Reply


apperception March 27 2005, 22:56:47 UTC
apperception: It would be a nice glimpse into a rather odd piece of real estate

Awww! :)

Reply


Leave a comment

Up