Warning: Links are probably NWS

Oct 07, 2011 12:42

!!!NWS!!!Danny Guthrie Portfolio!!!NWS ( Read more... )

Leave a comment

Comments 5

staciadevi October 7 2011, 18:18:39 UTC
Hmmmm. I have mixed feelings about this project. I get the guy's desire - there's commentary on nudity, female comfort, poses taken from famous classic works, he looks at them fairly uninvovled/un-sexually (except that last one), power of age difference. Where this goes beyond art to creepy is that he used *current* students. Friends, models, former students - whatever, that's their choice. But that top model looks acutely uncomfortable - which she was probably posed to do - & the idea that the power dynamic is genuinely messed up - that she might be a student - bugs me.

Here's his statement on the photos: http://www.art.msu.edu/?page_id=102

Reply


jennytheonly October 10 2011, 20:55:34 UTC
I have no problem with those pictures at all, and don't find them creepy.

Honestly, I'm confused as to why there is any question at all that the models were possibly unwilling.

Reply

staciadevi October 13 2011, 04:43:55 UTC
Meh, I still don't think current students shoulda been invited to participate. Sure, maybe they'd want to, but someone who has power over your grades & therefore your future..I dunno. I probably sound hung up or something, I just don't think that is kosher. What if he wanted some student to do it, & she didn't, & he flunked her?

The pictures themselves don't bug me.

Reply

jennytheonly October 13 2011, 13:02:35 UTC
It's just weird to me that you jump to the scenarios that prove he's evil. It just seems really biased thinking.

Reply

staciadevi October 13 2011, 13:48:23 UTC
Well, that's true. I saw enough academic BS at Rutgers that I'm pretty cynical about professors, etc. & I jumped to --a-- scenario, not multiple ones. Point taken.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up