Comments | likethegun_lims: RESULTS - challenge twelve, round nine

zestyzorra in likethegun_lims

RESULTS - challenge twelve, round nine

May 26, 2013 20:03

Thank you, voters! Unfortunately, we have to say goodbye to one iconmaker this week.

There isn't a banner maker assigned for this week, so if you'd like a banner, please say so in your comment & I will make you one.

( results for challenge twelve )

r.9 challenge twelve, results, round nine

Comments 4

naive_astronaut May 27 2013, 06:27:01 UTC

wow, that's totally unexpected!
#4, please? :)
unscreened is fine.

zestyzorra May 27 2013, 10:10:15 UTC

Favorite ( ... )

afastmachine May 27 2013, 07:00:15 UTC

I'll take #2, unscreened please :)

zestyzorra May 27 2013, 10:09:41 UTC

Favorite:
Reason for 1st icon: I love the crop and composition, although the text would benefit from standing out a bit more.
Reason for 2nd icon: Bold composition and colors, but I think it turned out really great.
Reason for 1st icon: This icon is so beautifully lit and the quality of the coloring & sharpness on Dean's face is great. So is the text!
Reason for 2nd icon: I do think the text here covers up just a smidge too much of Dean (he's so pretty, even when he's EMO, lol), but it just so well done that that is forgiven. Also, the coloring is so beautiful and vivid.

Least Favorite:
Reason for 1st icon: Tiny unreadable font is not always a problem but in this case I feel like the image alone has not enough going on, so I feel like I'm missing the point.
Reason for 2nd icon: For this one the statement or possible use are too ambigious to me. I feel weird about adding the 'certified' stamp to the character quote.