lims Challenge #5 Results

[dresstokill]

Really sorry to see so many iconmakers eliminated for not getting an icon in this week. This week, we'll be saying goodbye to three icon makers, instead of four, due to a tie for the forth "lesser quality" icon.
ELIMINATED PARTICIPANTS

monster
nellenoir
eye_knead_name







:( We're really sorry to see you guys go!


We also had a tie for the people's choice icon, so this week, we have two :)

FAVES, MODS CHOICES & BEST USE OF THEME

People's Choice
boni_bon
Mod's Choice:
Emma-Jane
a_brokenangel
Mod's Choice:
Daphne
goingooo
Best use of
theme
nellenoir











ICONS + VOTING BREAKDOWN

01


02


03


04


05


06


07


08


09


10


11


12


If your icon is not listed below, you did not receive any votes (good or bad)

Bad Votes
01. 4
02. 1
03. 3
04. 3
05. 2
06. 2
07. 1
08. 7
09. 9
10. 3
12. 1

Good Votes
03. 2
06. 5
11. 1
12. 1

Positive comments
The positive comments don't match the 'good' vote counts, since a lot of people don't comment on their favorite icon :)

03 - Ooh, pretty! Sorry...coherency...The textures, text, and especially coloring of this icon are all just gorgeous. It looks lovely.
03 - Nice colouring! :D
06 - I love the coloring and it's a very unique crop!
06 - The croping and colouring is beautiful.
06 - The lighting burst has been really popular lately, and usually it looks bad, but you did it well. I like the colors, the placement of the lighting burst, the cropping, the exclusion layer (I'm guessing that's what it is), and the tiny text. It all looks great :)
11 - Good colouring, especially the colours over the text.
12 - Very original

If you wish to see your comments, please comment in this post with the number of your icon. I will add them in a reply and then delete it, so you have to have email notification to read them. If you don't, please let me know you'd rather receive them by email (and give me your email addy).

Thank you guys for participating, challenge #6 will be posted tomorrow!