Round #8 - Challenge #2 - Results

[hermionesparkle]

Thank you for voting!

Eliminated:

Comments

[latemorningicon]

wow thank you so much C: i would love to see my comments when u have the time.

[hermionesparkle]

Negative:
#3 - The crop and color is nice but there is too much brightness and contrast.

Positive:
#3 - The green is really gorgeous and the entire crop/composition of this icon is beautiful.
3 - It's such a difficult scene to color, and you did awesome! :)
#03 - nice colors, the image isn't oversharp nor is it blurry and overall the icon has good bright color balance
3. Overall beautifully made.

[dance_the_dance]

Thank you for MC. :D I'd like comments for #5. :)

[hermionesparkle]

5. The idea of the black to create the space is good but it looks like the creator wasn't too sure how to go with this image with thrying to create the space and hiding the background. Another image selection might have been a better choice and working on that black effect more might have been better for this.
#5 - reasonNice crop but icon is oversaturated and oversharpened (especially around her face)
#5 - The way it cuts off in her forehead looks really awkward.

[cozycaffe]

comments on 2 please

[hermionesparkle]

Negative:
2 - It's an awesome crop and colors, but the image quality is low (blurry-ish and pixelated) in some parts of the icon, such as the hand.
#02 - the image looks a bit oversharpened around Angel's spine and hand and the archway of the door

Positive:
#2 - Gorgeous coloring and crop.