wikipedia adventures .. and BARBIE

Jun 04, 2009 17:34

some time ago, it was shown to me that the barbie article on wikipedia said she went to stuyvesant high school. (or that the school that she went to was modelled after it ( Read more... )

Leave a comment

Comments 7

lampbane June 4 2009, 22:06:37 UTC
Um, because it was?

http://nymag.com/nymetro/urban/family/features/2033/

Also:

http://community.livejournal.com/stuyvesant/9245.html

(And your reasoning is flawed - the article never said that "Manhattan International High School" was her stated school at the time of the doll's creation [there was no stated school back then, "Willows High School" was added in the 60's line of Random House books] - but it was at the time of the creation of the Generation Girl line, back in 1999.)

And I've added it back, now with citation, which I wanted to add years ago but could never find.

Reply

luminifer June 4 2009, 22:28:12 UTC
cool, yeah, i'd forgotten to say "you should add a citation if it's correct".

you know, you might want to make it clear that it's retcon...

Reply

lampbane June 5 2009, 01:06:39 UTC
Like I said - I had to find the citation first. New York didn't have online archives at the time, I think, and this also might have been before Wikipedia became citation-happy (not a bad thing, just making a note). If I couldn't find the article, I'd have a hell of a time trying to cite the actual book (which I just found) and making comparisons - which might count as original research.

God, I wish I could also cite the original Random House novels, but it looks like Google hasn't scanned them in yet, and even library records are sketchy. Kills me that the library had them when I was a kid and I didn't care.

Reply

luminifer June 5 2009, 02:38:43 UTC
you can cite things that aren't online, you know. just put the ISBN and page #, or not even that much...

it's really just to stop people from putting in random facts... it's checked up a lot less than one would think.

Reply


fiendess June 6 2009, 03:02:01 UTC
why would it have been jake dobkin?

Reply

luminifer June 6 2009, 04:36:08 UTC
because he went to stuy and is a famous internet personality.

and i think it was gothamist that pointed out that it said that, which could point either way.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up