American Idol Top 11: Motown Night

[manman85]

I am just catching up on Idol, so I decided to write a little something for Kyle. I know what happened on elim night so all of this is still totally relevant.

Casey Abrams, “Heard It Through the Grapevine” - This is just okay. I don't really like the grittiness in his voice. It sounds kind of disgusting, like he has to clear his throat all the

Comments

[a_good_storm]

I wonder the same thing about Paul every single week. Thanks for writing for me, darling!!

[bucklind]

I'm curious if you forgot to rank Paul on purpose or by accident.

[manman85]

Accident. Guess that proves how memorable he was. VFTW tweeted at me! I think I'm going to start following them again since they support Paul.

[bucklind]

I noticed they have a whole crew of people they support this year! But it seems like Paul is their fave. I think he was less memorable this week because he wasn't stumbling around like a drunken uncle on a karaoke cruise ship (tm Simon).

[manman85]

Yeah, the four horsemen of the Idolpocalypse!

[convalesco]

It's funny how our opinions differ. I think my top 5 is Pia, Thia, Scotty, Stefano and Twitchy McGee (in no certain order).