Comments | marchingharp: (без темы)

marchingharp

(Untitled)

Nov 18, 2005 15:37

i am extremely disappointed and angered at what they did to harry potter. its awful! ok yes..some parts were really funny, but overall..i am really disappointed.

Comments 4

smileyqtmeg November 18 2005, 19:01:59 UTC

personally, i think they would have been infinitely better off if they had done it titanic-style and just made it in to two movies. there's just no way to condense such a huge book down to 2 1/2 hours without losing all of the depth. soooooo much got compromised (or eliminated), it seemed like more was cut than saved. i still thought it was pretty good, though. and i only say that because the harry potter fan in me wants to give them the benefit of the doubt. =)

katemcgowan4eva November 18 2005, 20:04:45 UTC

Yeah...like...it was so good. But it could have been SO much better had they left everything in.

katemcgowan4eva November 18 2005, 20:05:07 UTC

And you know what else? There were NO house-elves!!!! >:(

marchingharp November 19 2005, 08:24:55 UTC

i know!! thats what really upset me. SPEW was a large part and winky and dobby played a large part! they should have at least put winky and dobby in. ok i guess you guys are right..it was still good. a little :)