POP QUIZ (warning: dorky/nerdy word knowledge question)

Apr 19, 2007 13:32

Question: Does Chicago Manual of Style prefer "line-up" or "lineup ( Read more... )

Leave a comment

Comments 4

loudmouse42 April 19 2007, 22:59:20 UTC
amusingly, I think I would spell this differently depending on the context; police lineup, I line-up the cups.
Why ask you?

Reply

midnightblu2002 April 20 2007, 20:38:19 UTC
the word appeared in both forms in a business eLearning course I am editing at my work.

"line-up" first, then "lineup". Often the hyphenated is the preferred British spelling, but not so in this case. When style manuals express no preference I like to ask other folks their opinions.

I chose lineup as the preferred option.

Reply


kamitatsubane April 20 2007, 19:51:57 UTC
I believe that as long as the style of writing is consistent, you can use either hyphenated or non-hyphenated words. Although, in this case, I think that lineup is the best word, since it is available non-hyphenated and is a noun. Makeup, for example is probably a heck of a lot more common in usage than make-up.

The entire point, I think, is to alleviate any confusion by eliminating ambiguity. For example, you'd write bookstore instead of book-store since bookstore is in the dictionary. But if the bookstore sells used books, it is then a used-book store instead of a used bookstore. Heh.

If use or lack of a hyphen causes ambiguity of a sentence, you adjust the word. If it does not, then it all depends on your writing style. You just have to be consistent. ^^ If you wrote "lineup", "mock-up", and "make-up" all in the same book, you'd have a lot of critics.

Reply

midnightblu2002 April 20 2007, 20:37:51 UTC
agreed.

the word appeared in both forms in a business eLearning course I am editing at my work.

"line-up" first, then "lineup". Often the hyphenated is the preferred British spelling, but not so in this case. When style manuals express no preference I like to ask other folks their opinions.

I chose lineup as the preferred option.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up