Comments | mike_smith: <a href="http://weirdal.0catch.com/txt/27.list.html" class="external">http://weirdal.0catch.com/txt/27.list.html</a>

mike_smith

http://weirdal.0catch.com/txt/27.list.html

Oct 31, 2005 00:30

OK, I gotta go back to work tonight, so I'm gonna make this one quick.

( All right, then, Chapter 27? Dammit, I thought I already did this one. )

halfbloodprince

Comments 46

jim_smith October 31 2005, 06:07:41 UTC

I'm sorry...who killed who again?

widor_toccata October 31 2005, 08:37:15 UTC

in case you actually weren't sure,

HBP Spoilers below!

Snape killed Dumbledore for Draco

jim_smith October 31 2005, 15:29:02 UTC

I'm settin' up a joke here, but I have to wait for Mike to get home from work and finish talking to his Playstation.

mike_smith October 31 2005, 17:18:24 UTC

Snape killed Dumbledore.

Thread 7

flaxenescapee October 31 2005, 07:03:05 UTC

And you're hot too, might as well marry me RIGHT NOW.

Plzkthxbaiii.

trishalynn November 2 2005, 12:28:10 UTC

Hey! Your plan worked!

flaxenescapee November 3 2005, 20:48:16 UTC

Did it? I have a cold, so I can't see/think/anything properly.

widor_toccata October 31 2005, 08:36:14 UTC

i like this review a lot. it helps my argument with friend as to whether snape is evil or not.... thanks!

merenwen_81 October 31 2005, 10:29:35 UTC

Dumbledore must have known he would die and he may have even ordered Snape to do it (remeber their fight earlier in the book). Snape may not be evil, but he's sure as hell not a good guy and he's probably only on his own side.

Trelawney, for once, saw this coming. I don't know if that has anything to do with anything.

aberranteyes October 31 2005, 18:28:34 UTC

Dumbledore must have known he would die

Big Al's behavior from Chapter 3 onward has long struck me as consistent with someone who knows his days are numbered and is putting his affairs in order. Then again, as early as book 4, I was expecting him to die no later than this anyway.

merenwen_81 October 31 2005, 18:42:31 UTC

The old guy with the beard must die. :) I also guessed who would die before I started reading book six, but not how he would die. Snape killing one of the only people who has shown kindness to him was a bit of a shock, even if he had tons of reasons to do it.

(The comment has been removed)

jim_smith October 31 2005, 15:27:13 UTC

I discovered Summary Executions a couple of months ago, posted to my journal about my favorite one (guess), and Mike's been calling him that ever since.