"The Oath" review

Feb 01, 2009 00:41

I wrote a BSG review for this week's ep. Spoilers under the cut, obvs.

The Courage of Your Convictions )

Leave a comment

Comments 34

lls_mutant February 1 2009, 21:26:31 UTC
Great review, and I really liked the point about Gaeta symbolically killing off or putting away parts of himself. I've seen speculations that his leg is going to be infected and he'll succumb to illness/infection, and in a way that sort of goes with the same thing; that it's a sickness in body and soul that kills him. Poor Felix ( ... )

Reply

millari February 2 2009, 22:08:46 UTC
Weird. I was just replying to another comment to this post and noticed from the formatting that I seem to have replied to your comment by leaving a general comment, not replying directly to you. So you may have never seen this reply to your comment. Hope you didn't think it was ignored. :D

Reply


millari February 1 2009, 22:11:27 UTC
Awww! I like it too! Hell, he's done crap sorta like that for Starbuck, he oughta do it for Gaeta too! Hell, he voted to acquit Baltar, damnit. How can he be harsher on Gaeta?

Since I wrote this review, I have come to be convinced that Gaeta's entering this with eyes more wide opened than I thought. In retrospect, I think Zarek killing Laird and Gaeta saying nothing was the moment when Gaeta went in with eyes open. Note that immediately after that, he stops being subservient to Zarek, stops calling him Mr. Vice President, and says things like, "get on that frakking ship." I think he's figured out where things are going and is just hoping he can stay in power long enough to make a difference. I don't think he's yet imagining himself as permanent commander of Galactica - although that is what he's signing up for if this mutiny is successful - only because I think the PTSD he's suffered from the Raptor murders has caused him to have a sense of a foreshortened future ( ... )

Reply


Leave a comment

Up