I'm not sure why there aren't any comments for this already o_O;; I really liked it. Sounds like what actually would happen. It being hot was a plus, as well :D *adds to memories*
a nice fic, but....dyoklakoJuly 25 2006, 06:48:39 UTC
it was a nice introspective but the shifting was kinda awkward because we know the first speaker was Kaoru and then suddenly it shifted to Hikaru. i think a break of sorts could have been made to make the transition more effective.
still thank you for sharing what you've written as it is quite hard to write introspective Hikaru/Kaoru fics, make them in character and works.
I love it -- but I won't gush too much, as you already know my opinion. <333
In retrospect, I suppose I should have noticed what the above poster said about transition -- but it was smooth to me. I still don't see a problem with it, but transition is one of my own problems. I'm so sorry. ;3; If you ever want me to Beta for you again, I'll definitely work harder!
Again -- it's a gorgeous story. The introspect is wonderful, the actions are perfect, and everything works well together. I'm also stunned that there aren't more comments.
Don't feel sorry; I should have noticed the transition myself. Yet sometimes writers can be blind when it comes to mistakes. I'm definitely willing to let you beta again; however, I have no idea what other fandoms you're familiar with.
I don't really care about the quantity of comments-it's the quality of feedback that counts. Besides, I don't advertise much. So, it is my own fault, really.
I enjoyed this, but I'd also like to voice a bit of (along the way, this became a lie) concrit. I will say that I didn't notice a problem with the flow of the transition the first (but that wouldn't stop it not making sense to other people, my perceptions can be weird
( ... )
Wow, I honestly don't know what to say. I'm not offended by the critique at all, but love you for pointing all these things out. You didn't torment me at all. I really appreciate your thoughtful and very well-written feedback
( ... )
The "genuinely curious" bit was actually a commentary on my own slithers-question; I realized midway through it could be interpreted offensively. And snails!
I'm floored, because I don't think I've ever been called awesome before. *blushes* (What makes this even more flattering is that that's just how I've felt about most of the people I've friended. I am simply not worthy.) But you're welcome to friend me. I'll be sure to nose around your journal too, and then hopefully friend you back. ^_^
I'm actually afraid to take on fandom. XD But, if you're suicidal or a glutton for punishment or something (okay, the writing's not that bad, but I wouldn't call it good either), I have put up maybe 4 pieces of short original fiction on my lj. So, if you were morbidly curious about my writing style, anyway, you could get a sense for how bad it is.
Comments 15
I really liked it. Sounds like what actually would happen. It being hot was a plus, as well :D
*adds to memories*
Reply
Reply
still thank you for sharing what you've written as it is quite hard to write introspective Hikaru/Kaoru fics, make them in character and works.
Reply
Reply
Reply
Reply
In retrospect, I suppose I should have noticed what the above poster said about transition -- but it was smooth to me. I still don't see a problem with it, but transition is one of my own problems. I'm so sorry. ;3; If you ever want me to Beta for you again, I'll definitely work harder!
Again -- it's a gorgeous story. The introspect is wonderful, the actions are perfect, and everything works well together. I'm also stunned that there aren't more comments.
Reply
I don't really care about the quantity of comments-it's the quality of feedback that counts. Besides, I don't advertise much. So, it is my own fault, really.
Reply
Thanks!~
Reply
Reply
Reply
Reply
I'm floored, because I don't think I've ever been called awesome before. *blushes* (What makes this even more flattering is that that's just how I've felt about most of the people I've friended. I am simply not worthy.) But you're welcome to friend me. I'll be sure to nose around your journal too, and then hopefully friend you back. ^_^
I'm actually afraid to take on fandom. XD But, if you're suicidal or a glutton for punishment or something (okay, the writing's not that bad, but I wouldn't call it good either), I have put up maybe 4 pieces of short original fiction on my lj. So, if you were morbidly curious about my writing style, anyway, you could get a sense for how bad it is.
Reply
Leave a comment