Challenge 04 Voting

[naginis]

A skip has been used for violateraindrop.

Comments

[violateraindrop]

1 least quality:
3 - This was a hard one because I don't think that the icon is bad. One thing that does stand out here is the mix of different styles which doesn't work. The main image is very clean with natural looking colors and contrast. The blocks surrounding it look so different, especially in regard to contrast which makes the difference between the elements too jarring.

1 favorite:
5 - I really like the coloring and use of negative space!

[sandy79]

1 least quality:
#1 - Basically, the idea is great, and I love the crop, but for some reason, the pic is a tad too dark/saturated, and therefore Kate's eye looks like this is a cap straight from a horror movie

1 favorite:
#5 - great coloring, which adds to the cuteness of Grogu

[abyss_valkyrie]

1 least quality:
4-I feel like the texture on top and the bright lighting without much contrast takes away the focus from the characters here a bit.

1 favorite:
2

[arbdhax]

1 least quality:
4 - (reason): I can barely see the face of the characters, with a contrast effect over, and a better crop and composition, I think this will pop up the icon.

1 favorite:
5 - (reason optional): lovely crop, effects, and composition over the icon

[geckoholic]

1 least quality:
# - The crop offers no real focus and the icon is overcontrasted.

1 favorite:
#3 - Very interesting composition!

[naginis]

Can you give me a number for your first vote please? :)

[geckoholic]

Sorry! That's #1.