Leave a comment

Comments 11

eatyourfudge January 18 2008, 21:20:10 UTC
DDD:
So so sad.
But! It's fantasically written, and your use of the song is very well linked in.

Reply

ms_shalimar January 18 2008, 21:26:14 UTC
*hugs, tissues and cookies*

Thank you, I'm glad you enjoyed and I'm glad it somewhat worked :D

Reply


taversham January 19 2008, 18:46:42 UTC
:'(

I like how this fic goes full circle - from the quite upbeat beginning, through the grief, to the hopeful end.

It's so sad, but end is surprisingly comforting.

"If it was down to me, I'd never leave...but it's not down to me."

Love that line, and also "pausing to whisper a sorrowful goodbye to the recorded memory" is beutiful

Reply

taversham January 19 2008, 18:47:54 UTC
Gah, I can't spell beautiful.

Reply

ms_shalimar January 19 2008, 19:19:01 UTC
Thank you, I'm glad you enjoyed.

The ending, I wanted to be hopeful without being too trite or cliche...I'm glad it worked (I had a bit of a fight with my muses to get that one down at all)

*hugs and cookies*

Reply


dear_ralph March 3 2008, 03:19:58 UTC
I'm depressed...

in a GOOD way.

You're amazing.

Reply

ms_shalimar March 3 2008, 08:56:33 UTC
Aww, thank you *offers cookies and tissues*

Reply


anonymous March 15 2010, 18:01:23 UTC
Aww

Would have been an extra nice touch if Paul had sung the song by the grave.

Reply


livingsasquatch April 30 2010, 05:10:19 UTC
this is an excellent story. :) it really portrays the emotions it's supposed to portray, which is something not all writers can achieve. it's super sad :(

Reply


Leave a comment

Up