A discussion...

[mugglewitch1]

I recently read a post asking for good Hermione moments in the films. The more I think about the it, the more I realize I really hate Hermione in the films. I don't know what it is about her; she just annoys me to no end. Could be the super!hermione and taking over POA...could be stealing all of the Weasley's lines (although, I know that is the

Comments

[bronte7723]

The movie Hermione I hate the most is in CoS when she steals Ron's lines about Mudbloods.
She wouldn't know! All Hermiones knowledge comes from books and Mudblood would never be written down. It's ridiculous that she answers that and not Ron, the kid with experience in the Magical world. Otherwise. Meh.

[mugglewitch1]

too right. One reason I dislike her as well ;)

[baw61983]

I saw the movies first so that is kind of how I saw Hermione when I finally read the books (after PoA).

After reading the books, I can see the problem with stealing lines and some of the added parts. To be fair to Emma though, I think she did well with what she was given. I was a bit iffy with Goblet, but that could be due to the fact that I read the book then saw the movie.

I might be shunned, but that is just how I feel.

[mugglewitch1]

I like Emma...it's the way the character is written I hate. I liked SS at first cause I saw it before I read the books.

Why would you be shunned?