In response to Philbert's post...

[nannylease]

I'm very happy that Brenna got the boot because she annoyed me like no other. Out of the girls, I personally like Paris and Katherine McPhee the best. I like Katherine because she has the same talent that Kelly Clarkson did in the sense that she makes good, controlled singing look effortless. Yes, Mandeesa is good, but I feel that she needs a

Comments

[tnibopper2004]

I agree completely. Well, on almost all counts. IMHO, Taylor has a good voice but he's no Idol. And the whole Mandeesa doing ballet thing, lol. Brenna literally made me physically angry; the whole "makin money" thing was irritating beyond belief from the first time they gave her airtime. Because the thing is even if they truly want to make money they have to do the fakey "it's for the love of music blah blah" thing to be likeable. Anyway, my thoughts. Apparently I decided to put them here instead of in my own update. <3!