May 13, 2013 00:55
Sooo...has anyone seen it?
Really, this watching stuff as it comes out is way overrated, not a lot of posts and no fic as of yet.'
(OMG I get to use my Reboot icons again \o/)
ETA: Spoilers in the comments.
fandom: star trek
Leave a comment
Comments 21
Reply
Reply
Reply
Reply
Reply
Reply
(Note. I may be slightly biased since I do love the Star Trek... *g*)
What about you? :)
Reply
Reply
That said, I'd be really interested to hear your take on it! I've heard mixed opinions so far...
Reply
Hmm, I really mixed about it. I loved it for some great character moments, even though Kirk totally regressed the first half of the movie (or not even regressed, he was more mature in the beginning of the last movie than he was for the first half of this one), but too be fair, he was under a lot of stress, so I can excuse some douchey tendencies.
All the characters got some time to shine, some more than others: Scotty, Bones, Uhura.
Scotty pretty much stole the movie, IMO.
Was left wanting OT3 fic for Spock/Kirk/Uhura. Oh yeah, and I loved that Spock was awesome at being Vulcan until the point where he wasn't.
Reply
Storywise, I thought it was all over the place, feels like they're setting stuff up for the next movie, which is fine, but yeah, all over the place. Or maybe it feels that way for the way they had Kirk act for the sake of plot, I'm not sure.
They also shoehorned in some weird references. Like, I don't mind references that only Star Trek fans get, that's awesome, but some were really badly timed or only worked if you DIDN'T know anything about Star Trek, so why use a reference at all and not make shit up?
Also wasn't blown away by the villain.
I guess in the end I didn't think it was that strong a movie, but I loved that it brought back all the characters that I adore.
Reply
I'm disappointed to hear about the regression, but glad to hear about Scotty, Bones, and Uhura! I had heard things that made me wary of Scotty's plotline (mainly Kirk's treatment of him, to be honest) - I'm not sure how many spoilers you want in this comment thread, so I'll stop there. XD
I am seriously excited about the influx of fic that this movie will create, though.
Reply
Leave a comment