Dos

[newt_lucy]

Why would Professor Umbridge ban all student organisations? And how come the Gryffindor team still hasn't been allowed to reform? I think that's really very, very unfair. I mean, what's the point of having Quidditch at school if all four houses can't participate? And why would you let some teams reform and others not? It's silly. Gryffindor hasn't

Comments

[newt_barney]

I don't know. Maybe she's worried some of the clubs might be inappropriate, like.... I don't know, maybe a firewhiskey appreciation club or something? As for Quidditch, it is a bit strange to not let all the teams play. I'd think she might have something on the Gryffindor team, but then the only team she approved straight away were Slytherin, and I know the Hufflepuff team have been perfectly behaved so she couldn't have any reason to suspect them. I mean, we've been allowed now, but still. There was a wait. So I don't know that the Gryffindor team have done anything wrong either.

[newt_lucy]

But she doesn't need to ban all the clubs to do that!

[newt_barney]

No, she doesn't. But she doesn't always seem to think very clearly.

[newt_angelina]

Don't count the Gryffindor Quidditch team among those "most" clubs.