Iconathon 1 - Results 04
MOST VOTES
4 votes
4 votes
001: 4 votes
002: 2 votes
004: 2 votes
005: 4 votes
006: 2 votes
007: 1 vote
COMMENTS
Set 01 (love the effect on the first one, looks like the wind is kind of blowing them away)
#1 - The coloring is beautiful on the 1st one, and you did a great job with making the black and white one beautiful.
Set 01: The cropping of the colored one is great and the coloring is natural, but looks great. The cropping of the black and white shows the whole image, but in a very simple manner that complements the whole icon.
Set 02 (love the softened look on the bw one and how they used only Nicole for both icons)
#4 - Great coloring and cropping.
Set 04: The coloring and cropping of both icons is simple, but the contrast adds to the simpleness.
Set 05 (Most unique crops and coloring)
#5 - I love the color icon and the cropping of the b&w one.
Set 05: The coloring of the colored icon is great, and the adding of the text and texture look great all together.
I didn't vote for 4 and 6 because each of them were 2 icons of similar cropping, and they had very similar coloring on the non-bw icons so it didn't stand out as much to me.