Happy Valentine's Day to you, sweetie. And thank you for the birthday wishes!!
As for the DQ, let me say this about that: (1) Most everyone on your f-list and many more of us have had fics DQ'd. I have a PhD in English and had a fic DQ'd. (2) In my opinion, only gross errors should DQ a fic, and a few errors or typos should be pointed out to the nominated author to fix. (3) I do this for fun. Fanfic is not publishable and should not, imo, be held to the standards of formal publications. (4) I am sorry you had to experience this. Awards feel so good but they are run by individuals and groups that make sometimes arbitrary decisions. (5) This is all to say I hope this didn't hurt your feelings or impact your joy in writing fanfic the tiniest bit. Cheers.
Thanks Sensei, I was disappointed,but not discouraged. I agree it should be for gross grammatical errors. That one-shot had minor typo's at best. I'm just going to stay positive and hope for a Nom next round. You really did make me feel better though it's good to know I'm not the only one.
Sorry about the DQ. Your fics are just fine. I got DQ'd the first few times that I was nominated. The last time I got DQ'd luxken and knittingknots were able to fix the problems. Just keep writing and you will do fine and win awards.
Just think of it this way: at least you got something nominated! ^_^ I've never even gotten that far, lol! I have been DQed, though, for crossposting, though that was at Challenge Destiny here on LJ, not a big awards association like the IYFG.
I'd be more than happy to be your new beta, if you'll have me. You should probably ask for a backup, though, as I am delectable SunMod with four comms to mod, a demanding hubby, four equally demanding small children, and two RPGs that keep me busy.
But I think I'm up to the challenge, haha. You don't seem to be too demanding of an author. ^_^
Anyways. Congrats on the nomination, and also, congrats on the DQ! Something to be proud of, I think. XD
I think you had noms at IYFG this year, maybe not. I would LOVE you forever if you'd beta for me!!! Seriously I understand if you're busy, I would only use you for big important stuff, not every drabble I write, unless you really want to. I have a couple serials underway, do want on board? If not, I'll make due. I really just need a second pair of eyes. I'll pm you my email etc. Etc.
Comments 12
And thank you for the birthday wishes!!
As for the DQ, let me say this about that:
(1) Most everyone on your f-list and many more of us have had fics DQ'd. I have a PhD in English and had a fic DQ'd.
(2) In my opinion, only gross errors should DQ a fic, and a few errors or typos should be pointed out to the nominated author to fix.
(3) I do this for fun. Fanfic is not publishable and should not, imo, be held to the standards of formal publications.
(4) I am sorry you had to experience this. Awards feel so good but they are run by individuals and groups that make sometimes arbitrary decisions.
(5) This is all to say I hope this didn't hurt your feelings or impact your joy in writing fanfic the tiniest bit.
Cheers.
Reply
Reply
Reply
Reply
Reply
Reply
I'd be more than happy to be your new beta, if you'll have me. You should probably ask for a backup, though, as I am delectable SunMod with four comms to mod, a demanding hubby, four equally demanding small children, and two RPGs that keep me busy.
But I think I'm up to the challenge, haha. You don't seem to be too demanding of an author. ^_^
Anyways. Congrats on the nomination, and also, congrats on the DQ! Something to be proud of, I think. XD
Reply
Reply
And anything you send my way, I'll try to work on; if I can't do anything with it, I'll let you know. ^_^
Reply
Reply
Leave a comment