Comments | nietzschekeen: Let's talk about you and me.

nietzschekeen

Let's talk about you and me.

Jul 23, 2007 03:36

( Deathly Hallows? )

Comments 9

slickmc July 23 2007, 12:00:47 UTC

I'm still too incoherent. But Good. Definitely Good.

almostblue July 23 2007, 16:37:15 UTC

OH MY GOD YES.

It's my favorite book in the series now. I thought it was phenomenal.

nietzschekeen July 23 2007, 18:38:34 UTC

Oh, it's because Harry spends half the book "grasping Draco's wand", isn't it?!? ;-)

jetjetters July 23 2007, 17:15:27 UTC

I have mixed feelings. I have to reread it.

nietzschekeen July 27 2007, 00:40:03 UTC

Reread it yet?

landfill_sky July 23 2007, 17:22:05 UTC

Emotional. And a rollercoaster. And something was always happening.
And good. Very, very good.
Sod the hype and angst out there, fandom is NOT > canon. Nuh uh. It just doesn't work like that.

Som dodgy bits, but overall, very good.

nietzschekeen July 23 2007, 18:40:10 UTC

The only time I'll ever support a theory of "the creator ruined the story" is with George Lucas and the prequels. Because I think that was so based on making and using money that it's not even on par with his original work.

propaedeutic July 25 2007, 04:38:03 UTC

FRED!!!!! fred... why, why????? my heart broke. is still broken.
call me back i needs consoling...

nietzschekeen July 27 2007, 00:41:12 UTC

I *knew* she was going to kill off a twin. Also, dammit, my theories were all SO CLOSE and yet so far.

I was betting that:
(a) the Grey Lady was Rowena Ravenclaw
(b) the last horcrux would be a wand, which was part of four items making up the Deathly Hallows
and (c) Snape was in love with Lily.

SO CLOSE.